For many years, states have considered legislation requiring public agencies, local governments, schools, and other governing boards to fulfill contracts with products manufactured in the United States. Often, this legislation is limited to public works but sometimes the mandate is more broadly written to capture all information and communications technology (ICT). While ITAPS supports economic growth from domestic manufacturing, legislation of this type could limit the availability of ICT products and increase costs to taxpayers. ITAPS also maintains that given the rapid pace of innovation of ICT, governmental agencies will be challenged to maximize competition among ICT products and suppliers and achieve the highest possible value if these products are excluded.
Equally troublesome in “Buy American” proposals are the ambiguous terms used in the waiver processes for American-manufactured requirements. The bills often require a vendor seeking a waiver to either demonstrate that: 1) the requirement is inconsistent with the public interest; 2) the necessary manufactured product is not made in the United States in sufficient and reasonably available quantities and of a satisfactory quality; or 3) the inclusion of U.S. manufactured goods will increase the cost of the overall project contract by an unreasonable amount. In most instances, none of the key phrases -- “inconsistent with the public interest,” “sufficient and reasonably available quantities,” “satisfactory quality,” and “unreasonable amount” -- in reference to the increase of the cost of the overall cost increases to the project are defined, leaving the potential for unequal treatment across similar projects. Our position on “Buy American” bills is to seek an exemption for ICT products, which is consistent with the federal Buy American Act after recognition by the U.S. Congress that the information technology marketplace has become international in scope.
- ITI-ITAPS Public Comment On U.S. International Government Procurement Obligations (September 19, 2017)
ITAPS Business Association Coalition Letter on NY Buy America Proposal (March 01, 2017)
ITAPS multi-group business association coalition letter to New York Governor Cuomo and state lawmakers on the state's "Buy America" proposal sent February 16, 2017.
Why Restrictions on Domestic Sourcing Hurts the American Government, Jobs and the Economy (September 19, 2017)
America and technological innovation are synonymous. From revolutionizing society with the internet, to the smartphones providing us apps that drive our day, to the microchips powering the device you are ...
New York’s Buy America Proposal Will Boomerang to Hurt US Workers and Economy (March 01, 2017)
“Buy America.” Sounds good when you say it, but despite being well-intentioned, such policies simply do not reflect the reality of the modern marketplace and can ultimately serve to do more harm than good ...
ITAPS Concerned Trump’s Buy American Order Will Stymie Government Technology (April 18, 2017)
WASHINGTON—The IT Alliance for Public Sector, a division of tech trade group ITI, released the following statement today from Senior Vice President for Public Sector Trey Hodgkins reacting to President ...